MSI P55-GD65 - Mid-Range P55 for the Masses
by Gary Key on October 10, 2009 12:00 PM EST- Posted in
- Motherboards
MSI P55-GD65 Layout
The GD-65’s board design is from MSI’s standard issue performance series. The basically all black design with a blue hue for certain accessories is a great look. The subtle gunmetal finished heatsink designs are tasteful and certainly leagues better than their old rollercoaster units.
It is obvious a lot of thought went in the general layout as it is also very good, but not perfect. The single blue JMicron powered SATA port is located on the other side of the six black P55 SATA slots and is difficult to reach in an CF/SLI setup. Of course, we still have a floppy port (why?) and an IDE port on a board that is suppose to take us into the future, not back to 1995.
MSI utilizes a high quality DrMOS six-phase PWM setup on this board. Unlike traditional designs, each DrMOS phase circuit contains the MOSFET and driver IC in a single package. Based on our testing this setup will handle power requirements just as well as any eight to twelve phase design utilized on competing boards from Gigabyte, ASRock, ASUS or others. In fact, switching speeds are up to four times faster than traditional MOSFET/Choke setups along with a side benefit of cooler temperatures.
The GD65 supports dynamic power-phase switching along with onboard LEDs that notify you how many phases are active at any given time. MSI claims power is delivered to the CPU with 92% efficiency. We believe them based on clamp load measurements. Also, MSI has gone back to the drawing board on their heatpipe design with a new setup aptly named SuperPipes. No it is not a plumber’s dream come true, MSI’s heatpipes are now 60% larger at 8mm for improved cooling. In fact, DrMOS temperatures reached 36.3C under full load conditions with our i7/860 running at 4.3GHz with only our CPU cooler providing airflow around the PWM area.
The CPU area is generally open and will accommodate larger coolers like the Thermalright Ultra 120 eXtreme. Large push/pull coolers like the Vigor Monsoon III LT will block the first DIMM slot. A pattern we are seeing with just about every P55 board.
The floppy drive port (once again, why?), 24-pin ATX power connector, four DIMM slots, and V-Check block are located in the lower right hand corner of the board. This board supports dual channel memory configurations and 16GB of DDR3 memory when using 4GB DIMMS. Installing the memory with a video card inserted in the first x16 slot is easy.
The V-Check option is the blue plastic rectangle with six square holes. This box houses pins that offer voltage check points for VTT, DDR, CPU and PCH voltages. A user can take a multimeter and get a real-time readout of voltages instead of relying on BIOS or software readouts. We typically found readings to be within 0.01V~0.03V of what various software programs offered.
A low-profile heastsink design keeps the P55 chipset cool (not that it really needs it) and will not interfere with longer graphics cards in either slot. The six 3Gbps SATA ports offered by the P55 are along the edge of the board with right angle connectors. The only drawback is that this design can be troublesome in enclosures with the drive cage pushed up against the board but overall it is a preferred solution. The blue SATA port is run off the JMicron JMB363 as is the IDE port. We would rather see the IDE port dropped and the extra SATA port moved to the I/O panel as an eSATA option.
MSI includes two PCIe x16 slots (dual x8 with the second slot populated, both slots are run off the processor), two PCIe x1 slots (P55), two PCI slots (P55), and a PCIe x4 slot (P55). The second PCIe x1 and first PCI slot will be physically unavailable when utilizing a dual slot video card in both x16 slots.
MSI includes their OC Genie and bclock buttons in addition to a power button. However, somebody probably fell asleep in the layout department as MSI failed to include reset and clear CMOS buttons. The two buttons most overclockers are going to use at one point or another.
MSI's "OC Genie" is a great technology that offers a hardware based solution to automatic overclocking. Basically, the user shuts down the system, presses the button, and starts the system again. The OC Genie will automatically take the system through a series of tests to overclock the CPU and memory. The whole process takes only a few seconds when it works.
We say “when it works” as we encountered several compatibility problems with various power supplies. Out of the eleven power supplies we utilize for compatibility testing, five of them caused OC Genie to lock hard, each time requiring a clear CMOS event to recover from the lock.
When it did work, our Core i5/750 was clocked to 3.3GHz and our Core i7/860 was clocked to 3.7GHz. We wished for a little more speed on the 750, but overall, the voltages and memory settings were in the safe zone and if a user is nervous about overclocking, this is a really quick and incredibly easy way to get additional performance from your system.
The I/O panel is loaded with goodies. We have seven USB 2.0 ports, PS/2 mouse and keyboards ports, a eSATA/USB powered port from the JMicron JMB363, IEEE 1394a port offered by the VIA VT6315N chipset, dual Gigabit Ethernet LAN ports via the Realtek RTL8111D chipset, optical out/coaxial out S/PDIF ports, and an audio panel that provides 8-channel audio output from the Realtek ALC 889 HD audio codec.
43 Comments
View All Comments
yacoub - Saturday, October 10, 2009 - link
Did I miss the list of PSUs that OCGenie had conflicts with? That would be important and helpful data to have in the article and I couldn't find it.Also, this board could be a winner if it didn't have so many archaic parts, like IDE and floppy. Really, MSI, drop those already! Even though there's probably no actual downside to having those items on the board, it actually does make me think less of it and discourage me from considering it. That plus the PSU and BIOS issues keep this from being my first choice.
Eagerly awaiting the other upcoming reviews. :)
michaelheath - Saturday, October 10, 2009 - link
On the first page, issues with Channel Well power supplies and OC Genie were mentioned as being a commonality between the GD65 and the GD80. What would be nice is if Gary would clue us in as to what particular models were giving him grief. Is it CWT's older designs? Is it newer DC-DC designed power supplies?The quagmire comes from the mention of Channel Well, Antec, BFG, and Corsair in the beginning of the article. Channel Well makes some Corsair power supplies, but BFG and Antec haven't used CWT recently for any of their power supplies.
Perhaps someone could clear the air, because I was planning on buying a high efficiency power supply with an MSI P55 board in the near future.
yacoub - Saturday, October 10, 2009 - link
Right. In particular, I am curious if the modular Corsair PSUs, which are a personal favorite, are on the list. The HX520W and HX620W, for examples.punjabiplaya - Monday, October 12, 2009 - link
Using an HX620 with my gd65 right now. works perfectly fine.michaelheath - Saturday, October 10, 2009 - link
...and when I said "Antec" I meant "Thermaltake", which has used CWT for many of their ToughPower units. My bad.punjabiplaya - Saturday, October 10, 2009 - link
I bought this board with a i5 750 and it's been rock solid. Noticeably quicker boot times than my old q6600/680i setup. The only problem I have is with the memory/XMP settings. I'm using a G-skill ddr3 2000 kit. When I set it to auto it shows the memory at being 1600MHz. When I reset and/or boot, it's set at 1333. However, if i set it to advanced or w/e the other setting is, it works and sets the memory at 2000MHz. Other than that, really good board and exceptional value for the price.punjabiplaya - Saturday, October 10, 2009 - link
I bought this board with a i5 750 and it's been rock solid. Noticeably quicker boot times than my old q6600/680i setup. The only problem I have is with the memory/XMP settings. I'm using a G-skill ddr3 2000 kit. When I set it to auto it shows the memory at being 1600MHz. When I reset and/or boot, it's set at 1333. However, if i set it to advanced or w/e the other setting is, it works and sets the memory at 2000MHz. Other than that, really good board and exceptional value for the price.goinginstyle - Saturday, October 10, 2009 - link
Just wanted to say that I really like the new way you are introducing the motherboard articles with the results and conclusions right up front. This article and the mATX were really good.MadMan007 - Sunday, October 11, 2009 - link
Yeah it keeps me from just jumping to the conclusion page then back to read the rest of the article if I want to. Well done.jigglywiggly - Saturday, October 10, 2009 - link
Where be the conclusion